Daily Archives: August 24, 2012


More Wisdom from the Guy Who Brought You “Rape Can’t Get You Pregnant”

The New Republic has the article More Wisdom from the Guy Who Brought You “Rape Can’t Get You Pregnant”.

It’s fine for magazines to debunk the pseudo-science of people in the news, but they shouldn’t use pseudo-science in one of their arguments.

In the section  titled “Legalizing abortion didn’t make abortion safer” they quoted Dr. Willke  as saying:

“If, in fact, the elimination of illegal abortion eliminated back alleys, there should have been a perceptible drop in the number of women dying. That didn’t happen. The line didn’t even blip from 1967 to 1973 and 1974. … It just kept going down at the same slow rate. There was no evidence of a decline in mortality from legalization.”

Then to disprove what he said the article posits:

In any event, evidence that his claim was totally bunk was readily available by 1989. In March of 1987, the American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology published a study which read, in part, “Between 1972 and 1982 … [t]he overall death rate resulting from legal abortion dropped nearly fivefold, from 4.1 per 100,000 abortions in 1972 to 0.8 in 1982.”

In one case, Dr. Willke talks about the number of women dying.  In the other case they quote the death rate per 100,000 abortions.  Now if the death rate went down, but the number of abortions went up, then it is quite possible that the total number of deaths of women did not go down.

I am not saying that this is true.  I am just saying that people should not use arguments that are so easily ripped apart.  The New Republic is trying to show that Dr. Willke doesn’t know science, but they don’t show a great grasp of science themselves, or at least not statistics, math, or even numbers.

Chalk up another example of Greenberg’s Law of the Media – “If a news item has a number in it, then it is probably misleading.

You might find the rest of the article more enlightening.  Too bad they had to spoil it with this blunder.


What is Mitt Romney Implying?

I received the following email:

Steven —

Mitt Romney, the Republican nominee for president of the United States, just said this:

“No one has ever asked to see my birth certificate. They know that this is the place that we were born and raised.”

Take a moment or two to think about that, what he’s actually saying, and what it says about Mitt Romney.

Thanks,

Messina

Jim Messina
Campaign Manager
Obama for America

Maybe this gedankenexperiment (In German – an experiment carried out in thought only) suggested by Jim Messina belongs in a category with my previous post Why Do Republicans Celebrate Labor Day?

See, my science/engineering education wasn’t completely wasted.  This is where I learned the phrase “gedanken experiment” or just plain “gedanken”.  I bet it cost less than $15,000 in tuition, for all my years as a college undergraduate.  See how great inflation is for making your past debts shrink to insignificance?  I think we could use a little of that right now.


Romney’s Death Squad Ties: Bain Launched with Millions from Oligarchs Behind Salvadoran Atrocities

Democracy Now has the August 10 interview Romney’s Death Squad Ties: Bain Launched with Millions from Oligarchs Behind Salvadoran Atrocities. Why have you not heard of this 2 week old story?


Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney is facing new scrutiny over revelations he founded the private equity firm Bain Capital with investments from Central American elites linked to death squads in El Salvador. After initially struggling to find investors, Romney traveled to Miami in 1983 to win pledges of $9 million, 40 percent of Bain’s start-up money. Some investors had extensive ties to the death squads responsible for the vast majority of the tens of thousands of deaths in El Salvador during the 1980s. We’re joined by Huffington Post reporter Ryan Grim, who connects the dots in his latest story, “Mitt Romney Started Bain Capital with Money from Families Tied to Death Squads.” “There’s no possible way that anybody in 1984 could check out these families — which is the term that [Romney’s campaign] use, these families — and come away convinced that this money was clean,” Grim says. [includes rush transcript]

As I watched, in the 1980s, the news of unfolding events in El Salvador, I was struck by the fact that extremely wealthy people in countries around the world seemed to have a certain sympathy for the situations that each such family faced. It is no surprise, therefore, that wealthy families in one country could aid and support and take aid and support for and from similarly positioned families in other countries.

If you watch the video, you may understand why Romney makes such a big deal of Obama going around the world apologizing for some of the atrocities committed by the USA.

As George Bush once advised politicians, “Never apologize.”

At about 24 minutes into the video there is a reading of some quotes from Greg Grandin’s book Empire’s Workshop: Latin America, the United States, and the Rise of the New Imperialism about the situation in El Salvador:

The problem was that the military groups had very little popular support due in large part to the fact that they were “preternaturally violent.” According to Reagan’s own ambassador, Robert White, their solution to the crisis “was apocalyptic: the country must be ‘destroyed totally, the economy must be wrecked, unemployment must be massive.’ and a ‘cleansing’ of some ‘3 or 4 or 500,000 people’ must be carried out”

Romney said he learned a lot from his Latin American investors. One of the things I have been fearing for a long time is that the quote above is one of the things that Romney (and the Republican Party) has learned about solving our economic problems.

Another piece of information from the video was the one about Romney’s company paying an 88% annual return to its investors over two decades. If you are an experienced investor, you know that such results are impossible to produce legally and honestly.